Culture

You Can Be the Prettiest Rose and Still Not Be the One They Pick



I saw a post floating around Facebook that stopped me mid-scroll (which, in 2026, is the emotional equivalent of a spiritual awakening):
“You can be the prettiest rose ever, but if they like lilies, it won’t matter.”

Rude. Accurate. Personally offensive.

Because somewhere between being raised to believe we are all special snowflakes and binge-watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer, many of us internalized a quiet but persistent myth:
If I am good enough, pretty enough, smart enough, and funny enough surely I will be chosen.

Cue Buffy, stakes high, destiny clear, hair somehow perfect after apocalypse-level exertion. She was the chosen one. Not a chosen one. Not one of several candidates pending review. The chosen one.

And yet, in real life?
You can be a rose. A spectacular, breathtaking, metaphorically award-winning rose.
And someone will still walk past you and say, “Do you have any lilies?”



Is there an existential crisis of not being someone’s favorite flower?

There’s a very particular sting in realizing you are not the preference.

Not because you lack value.
Not because you’re deficient.
But because you’re just not what they want.

And that’s where the psyche does a little interpretive dance:

“Maybe I should try being more like a lily?”
“What if I toned down the rose-ness?”
“Could I reinvent myself as a succulent?”

This is how we end up shape-shifting in relationships, jobs, and friendships trying to become more palatable, more aligned, more chosen.

But here’s the inconvenient truth:
Preference is not merit.

Let me say that again for the people quietly rewriting their personalities in the back row:
Preference is not merit.



Lets talk about toses dating tea people (a cautionary tale)

Let’s take it further.

You’re not just a rose. You’re also espresso. Bold. Intense. Slightly intimidating. Possibly the reason someone stayed up all night rethinking their life choices.

And they? They’re a tea person.

At first, it’s charming

“I’ve always wanted to get into espresso.”
“I like that you’re strong.”
“This feels exciting.”

For a brief, hopeful moment, you think: Ah. I have transcended floral and beverage limitations. I am universally appealing.

And then…

Their stomach starts to hurt.
Their sleep gets weird.
They miss their quiet chamomile evenings.

And suddenly, you’re not “invigorating.” You’re “a lot.”

This is the part where people often internalize:

“I’m too much.”
“I should tone it down.”
“Maybe I’m the problem.”

But no.
You are not too much.
You are just not tea.


So, lets talk about the psychology of being “not it”

Here’s where it gets psychologically interesting.

Being “not chosen” can activate:

1  Old attachment wounds
2. Core beliefs around worthiness
3. That deeply human fear: “If I’m not preferred, am I enough?”

But what’s actually happening is far less dramatic and far more mundane:

We can admit humans have preferences.
Sometimes rigid, sometimes irrational, often not about you at all.

They like lilies.
They like tea.
They like quiet.
They like simple.

And you, magnificent, layered, slightly chaotic youare something else entirely.



Let’s engage in  reframing the narrative (without toxic positivity, because we don’t do that here)

The goal is not to say:
“Yay! I wasn’t chosen! Everything is perfect!”

Let’s not lie to ourselves. It stings. It bruises. It lingers.

The goal is to shift from:

“Why wasn’t I enough?”

to:

“Why am I auditioning for roles that don’t require roses?”

Because somewhere out there in annoyingly, inconveniently, not always immediately known ways
there are people who:

1. Love roses
2. Need espresso
3. Thrive on exactly what you bring

And when you land there, something very un-Buffy-like happens:

You’re not chosen because you fought the hardest.
You’re not chosen because you proved your worth.

You’re chosen because you fit.

Effortlessly. Naturally. Without needing to become a hybrid floral beverage situation.



Here’s my final thought (from one unapologetic espresso to another)

If someone doesn’t choose you, it’s not always a reflection of your value. Sometimes it’s just a reflection of their taste.

And taste, as we all know, is wildly inconsistent.

So be the rose.
Be the espresso.
Be the thing that occasionally gives people emotional heart palpitations.

Because the right ones won’t need convincing.

They’ll just walk in, take a deep breath, and say
“Oh. This. This is exactly what I was looking for.”

2 replies »

  1. Perhaps “At Seventeen” too True

    All the Way Back to Grade School
    And the Reality of Not being
    Chosen First for the Sports

    Team hmm
    Not Chosen
    At All Not Chosen
    At All What Happens to
    the Not Chosen at all Indeed

    Dear Miriam There is No Choice

    Yet to Choose Their Life No Matter

    How Odd and Beautiful it May Be

    Indeed Just Daring to Smile
    as a boy in Middle School
    Halls Won the Disdain

    Of Wannabe Marching
    Christian Soldier Bully Boys
    Championed to Remove Empathy
    From Young Men to Draw Blood From
    Just Another Religion and Color of Flesh

    Unwarranted

    of Course

    too far away
    to Soak Our
    Soils and Souls with
    Red Until Enlistment Day

    i Suppose A Bright Side of the
    Dark of the Moon too Not Being
    Selected for ‘The Team of Tradition’

    So What Do Weeds and Wildflowers Do

    Well my Wife Was Beautiful Yet that Wasn’t
    Enough as the First Baptist Top of the Social Circles ‘Mean

    Girls’ of Course spit on my Wife for Having to Eat Reduced
    Price Meals even Free

    True Beautiful is Not
    Enough Either When
    “Soylent Green” is the
    Greatest Prize to Eat
    Kept Neatly in the Bank

    Anyway Living Life as an Outcast
    Weed One Forges Their Own Authentic
    Path even Through Concrete in the Winter

    if Necessary

    Hmm and Even Science
    Shows that the so-called
    Winners of Grade School

    Often Fall Far Behind in Future
    Life Still Relishing the Glory Days

    Without the Fire of Weed that Colors Life

    In ways
    of Never
    ever Before

    Becoming Authentic
    Naked Enough Whole
    Complete Breaking Through
    Concrete Barriers in Frozen Winter

    And Turning
    Brownest Lawns
    Green to the Chagrin
    of those Who Value Form

    Over
    Color
    With SMiLes…

    Anyway combine two
    weeds and wildflowers
    And Who Knows Legends

    Become

    Real

    Nah i don’t
    even need to know

    ‘At 17’ or even 66..:)

    Like

  2. That is EXACTLY my attitude about readers for my fiction: the RIGHT readers will love my little quirks – just down their alley.

    The RIGHT readers will tell their friends (and have).

    The RIGHT readers like the length of the novels in my mainstream trilogy – and the way I use that space. They won’t think I write too long – just be surprised when it’s over. Here’s an early review comment I found charming: “…this is a big honken book, but I didn’t know that until I had been reading for several hours, and had only finished 17% of the text. However, I compare it to the Thanksgiving feast we just celebrated at our house; some books are sandwiches, others are a bag of burgers from Checkers.”

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Cancel reply