Culture

Let the dinner be dinner

There was a time, not long ago, although it now feels like it existed in sepia tones, when dinner was just dinner. A plate, a fork, maybe a passive-aggressive comment about who didn’t unload the dishwasher, and if you were lucky, a moment of connection wedged somewhere between the carbs and the complaints.

Enter the concept of innovation. Or, as it’s increasingly known, “please God make the stock price go up.”

Somewhere in a sleek conference room, a group of very well-paid adults decided that what pasta sauce has been missing all these years is surveillance. Not flavor. Not less sodium. Not a jar that doesn’t require the grip strength of a CrossFit champion. No. What we needed was a device. A recording device. At dinner. Brought to you by your friendly neighborhood marinara.

Because nothing says “family bonding” quite like, “Hold that thought, sweetie, let me make sure the sauce is capturing this.”

This little technological garnish is being sold as a way to bring families together. To encourage storytelling. To keep phones away from the table. Which is adorable. Truly. It’s like saying, “I’m going to help you quit caffeine by introducing you to cocaine.” The logic is creative.

If the goal is to be present, to actually be with one another, then why in the name of all things al dente are we introducing yet another device into the sacred, shrinking space of human connection?

We’ve reached a point where silence makes us itchy. Where a pause in conversation feels like a system error. Where we are so afraid of missing a moment that we’ve decided to record all of them, presumably so we can never listen to them again but feel very accomplished knowing they exist.

And let’s talk about the elephant in the roor rather the microphone on the table.

We are being asked to trust that this device, lovingly co-branded by a pasta sauce company and a storytelling nonprofit, is simply there for the warm fuzzies. That it won’t “listen” in any meaningful way beyond your Uncle Joe’s retelling of the same story he’s told since 1998. That it won’t pick up on keywords. That it won’t, I don’t know, subtly nudge your future purchasing habits because you mentioned “garlic bread” three times in one sitting.

Sure. Of course. And I have a jar of completely sentient-free marinara to sell you.

Here’s the thing. Connection does not require a gadget. Unity does not come with a user manual. And presence isn’t something you can outsource to a device that needs charging.

If you want phones off the table, you can take them off the table. No app required. No firmware update. Just the radical, almost rebellious act of saying, “Hey, let’s try being here. Together. Unrecorded.”

Because the beauty of those moments has always been their impermanence. The half-finished stories. The laughter that comes out wrong. The arguments that start over nothing and somehow end in dessert. They don’t need to be captured to matter. In fact, capturing them might be the very thing that flattens them.

Not everything needs to be optimized. Not everything needs to be monetized. And not everything, despite what the market may whisper in its caffeinated, erratic way, needs a gadget.

So here’s a thought. A modest proposal, if you will.

Let the sauce be sauce.
Let the dinner be dinner.
Let the stories live and breathe and disappear like they’re supposed to.

And maybe, just maybe, when the jar starts listening that’s when we say stop.

2 replies »

  1. Oh Dear Lord an Effort to Can Oral Tradition Using
    A Can Shaped Recording Device through the Spaghetti
    Sauce Manufacturer Prego Yep working Hand in Can

    With the Non-Profit StoryCorps Organization that has
    Been Preserving American Stories from Everyday Folks

    Ever since 2003 and ever since 2005 in Weekly Broadcasts
    of the Stories of Common Folk on the NPR Public Broadcast

    to the Oral Tradition Tune of 645 thousand efforts archived
    in the Library of Congress Perhaps before traditional Oral Tradition

    Goes Extinct
    Or More appropriately
    put transforms into Modern
    Tik Tok Avenues of Constant
    Distraction for Focus and Attention
    Span Limited to somewhere around 40 Seconds

    Additionally Seeking Fame and Fortune even More
    than Warm Human Lifetime Connections for Real

    Health and Wellbeing From Cradle to Grave as such

    Far Far away from the Old Dinner Table and Living Room
    Conversations and even further away from the Ancestral
    Dance that was the Most Prevalent and Used Device to tale
    the Village Story Then Have i exceeded 40 seconds of reading Now

    Yes for others hehe Yet not for me as i can go on all day long Yet there

    Was a Day Before at Age 4 that i couldn’t even put words together for an Oral
    Tradition Sentence Yet Amazed then at How my Elders sitting at the Dining Table

    or Living Room Where Living was actually Shared and Delivered in Oral Tradition

    Totally Immersing me in all the Sensory and Emotional Details of their Stories Putting

    me Into Whatever Situation
    They Were Free Verse
    Poetically Describing

    In Actual Emotional
    Song of Verbal Words

    Wow! Just Wow! Truly
    Amazed i couldn’t even imagine
    Being able to do that not at 4 not
    at 40 and Not Even until 53 far away
    in Decades after that Yet i thought to myself

    Why am i the only one who couldn’t tale stories
    among my Elders well the Hawk doesn’t Fall Out of
    the Sky and the Monkey doesn’t fall Out of the Tree

    Cause they Practice Their Craft of Flight and Climb
    Every Day without fail to Practically Taking their Last

    Flight
    and Climb

    Of Life so Yes i’ve been
    Practicing this for 15.6 Million
    Words transformed into EPiC Long
    Form Poetry on this Fancy Dancy iMac
    Digital Writing Device Yet in the Real World

    Whereas i Rarely had even a word More than Two
    Yes Just ‘Working Working’ when folks asked me what i had
    Been doing through 33 Years of Work in the Real World i am able
    Verbally in Song of Words to Do What my Elders Did It Just took me a while

    to overcome both the Autistic Word Blocks and Environmental Road Blocks
    Like Stuck in a TV through Most of my Leisure hours or a mindless Video Game

    Just Never
    Practicing

    being more than
    an audience and
    spectator of Real Life

    Anyway this device has
    worked for me

    With
    SMiLes

    And Yes the StoryCorps organization Now is only
    Selling 100 of these recording devices for 20 Bucks
    As Reported by the “Online MSN News Source”
    As It’s Obviously Just a Promotional Scheme to
    get donations for the Non-Profit Organization

    And of course Stories too i checked out the Website
    and was actually tempted to click on some of the Stories

    Yet Dear Lord

    i already Read Blogs

    That Function the Same
    Way with the Written Word
    However Text only Relates
    About 7 Percent of the Full Human Connection

    And Verbal Language Doesn’t Relate Nearly as
    Much as the Non-Verbal Language of a Real Flesh and

    Blood Head to Toe Dance of Life Together Around a Campfire

    Transcending Solo

    Life unto

    A Force Much
    Greater than only one
    Voice Yes the Force of Together…

    It takes 2 to 3 Minutes for the average
    human being to read the 618 Words above

    It takes me a few seconds yet i Have a whole lot of practice

    The Dance Provides the Attention Span and Focus the Lit
    Up Screen Generates Dopamine for focus too it was hard

    For me to read more than a Page in my Youth of rather Severe ADHD…

    A Lot of the issue
    Was Environmental

    Some of the issue was Genetics

    Yet there are many ways to adapt
    to both the Nature and Nurture of Functional Limitations..:)

    Like

I welcome your thoughts