Culture

The Psychology of Being Wrong: When Changing Your Mind Feels Like Losing



I’ve been thinking about something lately. Actually, I’ve been thinking about it a lot, which is probably a little ironic given the subject.

It’s called the sunk cost fallacy, and I suspect it explains more about our current political climate than we’d like to admit.

The basic concept is simple. We continue investing in something because we’ve already invested so much in it, even when the evidence suggests it’s time to reconsider.

We’ve spent the money, the time, the energy. We’ve made the commitment. Walking away feels like wasting everything we’ve put into it.

But here’s where it gets interesting.

What happens when the investment isn’t money? What happens when it’s an opinion, a political position or an ideology?

As a psychologist, I find this fascinating.

We know that repetition plays a powerful role in shaping our thinking. The more we repeat an idea, the more familiar it becomes. Familiarity can increase our perception that something is true, a phenomenon psychologists call the illusory truth effect.

And repetition doesn’t just happen inside our heads anymore.

We repeat our opinions in conversations, post them on Facebook, argue about them on X, share videos that reinforce them, comment on articles, and find entire online communities that enthusiastically agree with us.

We aren’t just thinking our opinions. We’re publishing them, defending them and building an identity around them.

And there’s the rub.

Once we’ve publicly declared what we believe, changing our minds becomes considerably more complicated. It’s no longer simply about evaluating new information. It’s about reconciling that information with the person we’ve presented ourselves to be.

Enter cognitive dissonance which is that uncomfortable psychological tension we experience when new information conflicts with an existing belief.

Rather than reconsidering the belief, we sometimes rationalize, dismiss the evidence or find another explanation that allows us to maintain our original position.

And the more we’ve invested in defending it, the harder that becomes.

There’s also something called identity-protective cognition. We tend to process information in ways that protect the beliefs and identities connected to the groups we belong to. In politics, this can be particularly powerful. Changing your mind may feel like betraying your side, disappointing your community or abandoning your tribe.

Social media adds rocket fuel.

Algorithms can repeatedly expose us to content that aligns with our interests and engagement patterns. We find our people, our arguments and our confirmation. The result can be an environment where we’re constantly rehearsing the same positions while rarely encountering meaningful challenges to them.

And then we wonder why conversations have become so divisive.

Think about political polling. I would LOVE to study the relationship between sunk cost thinking, repetition of political beliefs and people’s willingness to change their positions over time.

Nerd that I am, I’d want to know whether the number of times someone publicly expresses an opinion predicts how strongly they cling to it, even when presented with contradictory evidence.

Does publicly defending a position make someone more resistant to changing it? Does the size of their social network reinforcing that position matter? Does the willingness to change one’s mind vary depending on whether the belief is private or publicly documented?

And what happens when someone has spent years defending a political figure, a movement or a particular worldview? At what point does the psychological cost of admitting a mistake become greater than the cost of continuing to defend it?

Now, to be clear, sunk cost fallacy doesn’t explain every political disagreement, and strong convictions aren’t inherently irrational. Sometimes people hold firmly to positions because they’ve thought them through and the evidence supports them.

But there’s a difference between standing by your principles and standing by an opinion simply because you’ve spent too much time defending it.

Perhaps one of the most important intellectual skills we can develop is the ability to say: “I used to think that. I’ve learned something new. I changed my mind.”

That’s not weakness. That’s cognitive flexibility.

And maybe, just maybe, we need less energy spent winning arguments and a little more spent examining why we’re so determined to win them in the first place.

Because being wrong occasionally is part of being human.

Refusing to ever consider it? That’s a much more expensive investment.

PsychologistMimi’s thought for the day: You don’t have to keep paying for an opinion just because you’ve already invested in it. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is cut your losses, update your thinking and move on.

Even if Facebook remembers what you said five years ago.

Especially if Facebook remembers.

I welcome your thoughts