Culture

Love, Lies and a Little Thing Called Catfishing: Apparently, Even Cupid Has Gone Cybercriminal



I’ve been binge-watching streaming documentaries about scams lately. You know the kind. You start watching one at night, thinking you’ll just see how it ends, and suddenly it’s 1:30 a.m. and you’re three episodes deep into a story involving fake identities, international money transfers, imaginary fiancés and enough plot twists to make a Hollywood screenwriter jealous.

And I have questions.

Who ARE these people? How do they come up with these elaborate schemes? And, perhaps most importantly, how does someone fall in love with a complete stranger online and end up sending them their life savings?

I know people who have been scammed. I understand loneliness, wanting companionship and the desire to believe that someone out there finds you extraordinary. But the sheer scale of these scams is staggering.

Here’s the latest twist. A happily married gay man has spent more than eight years discovering that his photographs have been stolen and used to create hundreds of fake online dating profiles. People around the world have fallen in love with his imaginary online persona. The reported losses among victims who have contacted him? Approximately $1.4 million.

Imagine being an innocent bystander in someone else’s imaginary love story and having strangers threaten you because your stolen photograph was the face of their fictional boyfriend.

That’s not a rom-com. That’s a psychological thriller with a very unfortunate headshot.

But here’s the thing: Why are we so susceptible to these scams?

Psychologically, there’s actually a pretty good explanation.

First, there’s something called emotional vulnerability. Loneliness, grief, isolation and major life transitions can make us particularly receptive to connection. When someone appears to offer affection, attention and understanding, our brains don’t necessarily stop to conduct a background check. They respond to the emotional reward.

Then there’s the psychology of intermittent reinforcement. Scammers are masters at alternating affection with distance, attention with silence, and promises with crises. One minute you’re receiving declarations of undying love; the next, there’s an emergency involving a hospital, a passport or a mysteriously inaccessible bank account. That unpredictability can make people even more invested. We’re wired to keep pursuing rewards that arrive inconsistently.

There’s also confirmation bias. Once we’ve decided someone is genuine, we tend to interpret evidence in ways that support what we already believe. Red flags become misunderstandings. Inconsistencies become explanations. And that suspicious request for $8,000 becomes an unfortunate obstacle in an otherwise beautiful relationship.

Add sunk cost fallacy to the mix. After investing months of conversations, emotional energy and money, admitting that the relationship was fabricated can feel unbearable. The more someone invests, the harder it can be to walk away.

And let’s not forget the dopamine involved in anticipation, romantic attention and that little notification announcing a new message. Our brains enjoy rewards. Apparently, they don’t always care whether the person delivering them actually exists.

AI has made the situation even more complicated. Stolen photographs, fabricated identities, convincing messages, manipulated images and even synthetic voices can make deception increasingly sophisticated.

The uncomfortable truth is that these scams aren’t simply about stealing money. They’re about exploiting trust, attachment, hope and the very human need to matter to someone.

And perhaps that’s why they work so well.

I still find myself watching these documentaries thinking, “How could anyone possibly fall for this?”

But maybe that’s the wrong question.

A better question might be. What would any of us do if someone showed up at precisely the moment we needed to feel loved, seen or understood?

Because intelligence doesn’t make us immune to manipulation. Education doesn’t eliminate loneliness. And having a PhD certainly doesn’t come with a built-in scam detector.

Although I’m seriously considering adding one to my next software update.

In the meantime, if your online soulmate suddenly needs money to get out of an international airport, pay an unexpected medical bill or unlock a mysterious inheritance, perhaps pause before reaching for your wallet.

And maybe reverse-image-search that gorgeous photograph.

Because in the age of AI, catfishing and romance scams, the person you’re falling in love with might not even know they’re in a relationship.

Sometimes Cupid needs a background check.

I welcome your thoughts