There are few things in life as satisfying as an underdog story except maybe a perfectly toasted bagel with schmear on a Sunday morning. But this World Series? It’s pure underdog magic with extra innings of heart.

Who knew the Toronto Blue Jays would bring such a fight to the mighty Dodgers? The Dodgers’ lineup valued at over $148 million this year has met its match in a rookie who made just $57,204 this season. Trey Yesavage. Remember that name. A late call-up from the minors who somehow decided the World Series was the perfect time to make history setting a rookie record with twelve strikeouts against the juggernaut Dodgers lineup.

It was one of those nights that reminded me why I love baseball. I grew up in the Bronx, a few blocks from Yankee Stadium. The crack of the bat, the crowd’s roar is part of my DNA. Sure, I was a little heartbroken to see the Yankees lose to these very Blue Jays (my inner Bronx pride may have winced), but watching Trey on that mound, I couldn’t help but cheer. There was something beautiful about it like watching someone seize their moment and turn it into legend.

And then came the cutaway shot that melted America’s collective heart: Trey’s parents in the stands, eyes glassy, hands clutched, watching their son pitch his dream into reality. If that doesn’t make you feel something, you might want to check your pulse or your Wi-Fi connection to the human experience.

I’ll admit, after living a decade in California, I have a little bit of soft spot for the Dodgers. But the Blue Jays are winning me over with their grit, their heart, and their “let’s just play ball” attitude. They’re the team that reminds us that payroll doesn’t buy passion, and that sometimes the kid with the smallest paycheck throws the biggest game of his life.

And maybe that’s the moral of this season’s story.  No matter the odds, the budget, or the spotlight, the magic comes from those who show up and believe.

After all, as Trey Yesavage just proved, fairy tales aren’t just for Disney and in the summertime. They happen under the bright lights of October, too.